Experiencing an animal up close can be a highlight for many, and we understand people take part in these encounters because they enjoy being close to animals. While they may be well meaning, in the excitement it’s easy to overlook how the individual animal is experiencing the interaction.
Petting zoos often involve animals being approached, touched, fed, and sometimes handled by unfamiliar people potentially many times throughout the day. How these encounters are managed, including the opportunities animals have to move away from interactions or rest undisturbed can vary. Animals may have little opportunity to avoid contact or retreat from the noise, bustle, and unfamiliar sights, smells and people.
There are several welfare risks associated with petting zoos and other animal encounters, including distress and injury. What may feel like a moment of connection or positive interaction for us may be a very different experience for the animals involved.
An animal remaining still while being handled, doesn’t necessarily mean they are comfortable with the interaction. Many of the animals commonly featured in petting zoos, such as rabbits, guinea pigs, lambs, piglets, and poultry are prey animals, and being lifted or restrained can be frightening for them, particularly when they’re unable to move away from the interaction. Even gentle handling can cause stress and compromise welfare.
Signs of distress may not always be easy to recognise to those unfamiliar with the species or the individual animal. Some small animals may ‘freeze’ when frightened, others may turn their head away, crouch, hide, make repeated attempts to move away, or keep to the edge of an enclosure. Other animals become still or withdrawn. A quiet animal isn’t necessarily a comfortable one. This is one of the reasons why interactions need to be closely supervised by competent member of staff who can recognise signs of distress and intervene if an animal shows signs that they are uncomfortable. If these signals are overlooked, animals may experience repeated stress without enough time to rest, retreat or move away from people when they choose.
Young animals are especially vulnerable, because they are at an important stage of growth and development. Their care and interactions during this period need to be carefully managed to protect their health, welfare and support their development. This includes ensuring they have adequate opportunities to rest, learn and engage in natural behaviours, as well as protecting them from distress, injury and excessive disturbance. Some young animals may still be dependent on their mothers, so their need for appropriate maternal care and contact also needs to be considered.
The risks are not limited to distress. Animals featured in petting zoos can often be vulnerable to injury, particularly when they are young or small. Affection for animals does not necessarily come with an understanding of how to handle them or the knowledge, coordination, or maturity to respond safely when an animal struggles or tries to escape. This can lead to animals being injured if they are dropped, held without adequate support, or handled roughly, even by visitors who mean well. Rabbits, for example, have fragile spines and can sustain serious injuries if they struggle while being held incorrectly. Even minor incidents can have significant consequences.
Where animals are involved in petting zoos, appropriate safeguards need to be in place. The Australian Veterinary Association recommends that animals are non-invasively conditioned to accept appropriate handling through cooperative care and consent training, are closely supervised to ensure prompt intervention when welfare is at risk, and are given regular breaks in a designated separate area away from the petting zoo range.
Regulation of petting zoos and other animal encounters varies across Australian states and territories, and there is no single national standard specifically governing the welfare of animals used in these activities.
Some jurisdictions have more specific requirements than others. For example, New South Wales has Standards for exhibiting animals at mobile establishments, which include requirements relating to animal welfare, care, handling, supervision and exhibition. Victoria has a broader Code of Practice for the Public Display of Exhibition of Animals which covers areas including animal management, housing, handling, transport and veterinary care. While these measures are a good first step, there is concern that they do not go far enough to protect the welfare of the animals involved.
Under these guidelines, very young animals can still be exhibited in pens at shopping centres, agricultural shows, fairs, parties, educational institutions, or for filming and photo shoots for up to fourteen days at a time, with no maximum time limit for how long they’re featured and handled each day. Victoria’s Code especially takes a much broader approach to animal welfare and hasn’t been updated since it’s last variation in 1994, while NSW Standards are more extensive and recent with the latest version published in 2019.
Elsewhere, operators may be subject to little more than general animal cruelty laws, which tend to apply only after harm has occurred.
Petting zoos are often promoted as educational, but how these encounters are structured and managed matters. Interactions should encourage people to understand and respect animal’s needs, behaviour and individual choices.
If animals are presented as available to be picked up, touched, or fed without considering whether they choose to participate in the interaction, this may miss an important opportunity to teach people about respecting animals’ needs and choices.
Providing opportunities to observe animals behaving naturally, such as interacting with their environment or other animals they live with, while respecting their space and choices, can also help people learn about animals without requiring physical contact.
An encounter that lasts only a few minutes for us may be one of many for the animal. Before taking part, we should consider whether their needs are being met and their autonomy and need for space is being respected. Caring about animals means putting their welfare ahead of our desire to be close to them.
A meaningful experience doesn’t always need to involve physical contact, sometimes, the kindest way to enjoy an animal is to let them be. But while petting zoos and animal encounters continue to operate, RSPCA Australia advocates for compulsory welfare standards. supported by adequate monitoring and enforcement.
Subscribe today and we’ll keep you updated on all the latest campaigns, events and news.